What Are The Differences Between Brushed Motor And Brushless Motor?

Dec 12, 2023

What is a Brushed Motor?

A brushed motor is a fundamental and widely used type of electric motor that operates on the principles of electromagnetic induction. It is characterized by the presence of brushes and a commutator, integral components that facilitate the flow of electric current and drive the motor's mechanical rotation. In a brushed motor, the brushes, typically made of carbon, maintain physical contact with the commutator, which is attached to the rotating rotor. As electric current flows through the brushes and commutator, a magnetic field is generated, compelling the rotor to turn and produce mechanical motion.


What is a Brushless Motor?

Unlike the brushed motor, the brushless motor operates without brushes and a commutator. Instead, it relies on electronic commutation for precise control of the rotor's magnetic fields. At the heart of the brushless motor's design are electronic components, such as sensors (commonly Hall effect sensors), which detect the rotor's position. This information enables sophisticated control systems to precisely synchronize the energization of the motor's stator windings. The absence of brushes eliminates wear-related issues, significantly extending the motor's operational lifespan.


Performance differences between brushed and brushless motors

Brushed Motor Brushless Motor
Less torque per weight More torque per weight
Less torque per watt More torque per watt
More audible noise Less audible noise
Shorter lifetime Longer lifetime
Lower reliability Higher reliability
Commutator sparking  No sparking
More EMI radiation Less EMI radiation
May need airflow to cool the rotor Can be completely enclosed
Lower RPM Higher RPM
Easy to drive Hard to drive

 

Application Difference

Brushed motors are commonly used in household appliances and small industrial applications. Their relatively simple mechanical structure makes brushed motors suitable for a number of scenarios with relatively low cost and simple control, such as vacuum cleaners and power tools. However, due to the friction and wear caused by the contact between the brushes and the rotor, brushed motors have a shorter lifespan, are relatively inefficient, and may generate a certain amount of noise and electromagnetic interference.

 

In contrast, brushless motors are widely used in applications where efficiency, durability, and control are more demanding. Brushless motors are electronically controlled rather than mechanically brushed, avoiding the wear and tear problems caused by brushes, and therefore typically offer higher efficiency and longer life. They are commonly used in areas such as electric vehicles, aerospace, and precision instruments, where precise motion control and low noise are more important.

 

 

You Might Also Like